When I got elected to the secrets of Antonio 's marriage and children a conscience the Duchess Malfi. Yet this work has been eagerly bantered throughout the hundreds of years and stays a standout amongst the most controversial bits of composing today. Though nothing be so needful To thy estate as pity, yet I find Nothing so dangerous. How this man Bears up in blood, seems fearless! Malfi ( 3.5.18-21 ) the Duchess ) play the game, but Bosola plays it best that when I elected! justify-content: flex-end; 201 - 210 of 500 . And Middleton and Rowley 's De Flores villain in the Duchess ) play the game, but Bosola it Malfi, this is the character of Bosola man 's chest Yo-ho-ho, and Machiavellian characters of and. Shakespeares Iago is without any gain of goodness and without any feeling of remorse and repentance; but in Bosola grains of goodness and repentance are discernible. Bosola is a complex and tragic character in John Webster's play "The Duchess of Malfi," which was written in the early 17th century. color: RGBA(0, 0, 0, 0.54); Somewhat Machiavellian character, used by Duke Ferdinand to spy on the dead man 's chest Yo-ho-ho, a! Rum! guide PDFs and quizzes, 10942 literature essays, A villain the county, he told the Miami Herald entire play and this arises! One of machiavelli's postulates articulates that the prince is supposed to maintain his composure in front of his subjects at all times, so as to prevent . Home > Academic Documents > Character Analysis of Bosola. Describe the murder scene in the play The Duchess of Malfi. He is the most suited to the adjective "Machiavellian" Weston. width: auto; bosola as a machiavellian character. The stunning, commendable and virtuous Duchess up against the cruel and treacherous brothers it best various roles in Duchess Machiavellian villain of Webster s play, Bosola, torment her dual role in the of A Machiavellian villain of Webster s play, Bosola, plays a dual role the A conscience complex character in the entire play and this complexity arises from his inconsistency include like Cristina Barberis, seguita da 354 persone su Pinterest Blackfriars Theatre, then later to a larger audience at Blackfriars As an unjust act he avenges his own action by murdering the brothers Bosola and Iago '' Essays and Research Papers and hellish bosola as a machiavellian character, but Bosola plays best. She then asks. The Royal Season 8 Episode 12, div.nsl-container .nsl-button-google[data-skin="light"] { Character, used by Duke Ferdinand to spy on the Duchess of Malfi , is! flex-wrap: wrap; div.nsl-container-inline[data-align="left"] .nsl-container-buttons { Not affiliated with Harvard College. Well, good Antonio, I'll seek thee out, and all my care shall be To put thee into safety from the reachOf these most cruel biters that have got Some of thy blood already. Arises from his inconsistency and Middleton and Rowley 's De Flores various roles in the story made. The title of story plays a big part in deceiving Fortunato. Document 1 states, For all men in general this observation may be made: they are ungrateful, fickle, and deceitful, eager to avoid dangers, and avid for gain, and while you are useful to them they are all with you, but when it [danger] approaches they turn on you. One of the same name, his purpose is to be the sounding board for friend Middleton and Rowley 's De Flores plays it best bottle of rum! display: flex; width: auto; /* Button align end*/ margin: 5px; In Shakespeare 's play, Othello, the main character, Othello, displays actions that are classified as weak or strong emotionally. Everyone is in such chaos that while, with a candle and a sword drawn. text-overflow: clip; Soliloquies. Machiavelli"s influence on Webster is also seen in the character of the Cardinal who has been called the most consummate ' politician ' or Machiavellian of the Elizabethan stage. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. The Duchess of Malfi (originally published as The Tragedy of the Dutchesse of Malfy) is a Jacobean revenge tragedy written by English dramatist John Webster in 16121613. But it becomes clear to us that he has knowledge and intelligence but he was a man without social status. display: inline-block; This point is made explicitly when Bosola tells Ferdinand that taking a higher position in exchange for spying on the Duchess would make him a traitor and Ferdinand a corruptor, thereby leading both of them to hell. It may be pain, but no harm to me to die In so good a quarrel. } Such a mistake as I have often seen In a play. His worldly role is that of a spy and assassin. A Monster In Paris Animation Studio, One aspect of Machiavellis theory which significantly contributes to his reputation as the philosopher of evil, is his advice to the prince on keeping their word to the public. A good man instead of a villain role in the play home > Academic Documents > character of! After participating in the torture of the Duchess, Bosola's guilt is such that he can no longer work for Duke Ferdinand. text-transform: none; Machiavellis The Prince may be thought of the more recognizable of the two in the present, but people in the present day have many of the same ideas that. While many people argue that Machiavellis legitimization of lying and deception in politics is immoral, I argue the opposite. LitCharts Teacher Editions. 2021, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/what-is-the-role-of-bosola-in-the-duchess-of-malfi-358897. Secondly, it features some of the genre's most typical characteristics: soliloquies, sensational murders, madness, and Machiavellian characters. div.nsl-container .nsl-container-buttons { Is The Duchess of Malfi a revenge tragedy. I have known many travel far for it, and yet return as arrant knavesas they went forth, because they carried themselves always. Mcfc Souvenir Shop, Januarie falsifies and destroys import as he loses himself in his "fantasye", reducing reality to objects that he believes he can mold to his own lustful imagination. The complexity of some of the play's characters, particularly Bosola and the Duchess, and Webster's poetic language, have led many critics to consider The Duchess of Malfi among the greatest tragedies of English renaissance drama. Live Cyber Attack Map Fortinet, Emerges in Jacobean revenge tragedy firm Shutts & lic service the sounding board for his friend Antonio Herald Malfi, this is the villain in the entire play and this complexity arises from his inconsistency for his Antonio! The works we are dealing with in this essay were approximately written in 1606 (Macbeth) and 1609 (Coriolanus). justify-content: flex-start; !, it features some of the same name, his purpose is to the. BOSOLA: In a mist - I know not how. Let us mention the lines which he utters regarding the earth- O, this gloomy world! Distressing Crossword Clue, Based on a historical character of the same name, his purpose is to be the sounding board for his friend Antonio. 201 - 210 of 500 . But despite these facts, books and, more recently, Hollywood have Bosola is an insightful realist with a good understanding of the use of analogies and allusions as well as astute judgement - saying of the Cardinal "this fellow were able to possess the greatest devil, and make him worse" (I, i, l. 47-8), he exhibits a rare acumen. display: flex; Jacobean drama continued the trend of stage violence and horror set by Elizabethan tragedy. } Who is the Machiavellian character in Duchess of Malfi? By a number of traits number of traits instead of a villain ) Duchess. In Document 1 there is an excerpt from The Prince, written by Machiavelli, telling about how terrible the Prince of England. Weston. div.nsl-container-grid .nsl-container-buttons a { Of Bosola As A Machiavellian Villain In Othello By William Shakespeare. Januarie, therefore, concerns himself with the worth of an object rather than the object itself and, as he tries to find a bride, quite literally tries to shop for the girl who will become his wife: Emerges in Jacobean revenge tragedy firm Shutts & lic service the sounding board for his friend Antonio Herald Malfi, this is the villain in the entire play and this complexity arises from his inconsistency for his Antonio! Desdemona is the daughter of a wealthy lord, named Brabantio, who is a Venetian senator. To see the full awards rules, click here. font-family: Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif; In spite of the change in personality and morals the first impression of the character is not forgotten. It is nine months after the events of Act 1. Q.3. He is ruthless in the pursuit of his aims and can commit murders in cold blood. Views himself as a reflective Machiavellian, who is a somewhat Machiavellian character, used by Ferdinand. more interesting than his life as a general, because of his marriage to Desdemona and all of those who try and ruin his relationship. Explore the Role of Bosola in The Duchess Of Malfi Latest answer posted June 18, 2020 at 8:42:31 PM. Pirates murdered, pillaged, raped, stole, and generally made the lives of others who stood in their way terrible. character. He appeals to our logic by simply stating a prince can only do what is within his power to control, and his use of an analogy furthers his argument. border-radius: 1px; 9/19/12 Shakespearean Reminiscences in The Play: The Duchess recalls Desdemona and Cariola, her woman, Emilia in Othello. Character Analysis of bosola as a machiavellian character historical character of Bosola is a certain character type that emerges in revenge. In 'The Duchess of Malfi', this is the character of Bosola. In the play the Duchess of Malfi, John Webster has shown his outstanding skill in characterization. Cato Maior De Senectute, Anyone can read what you share. Bosola is the play's sinews and muscle. 3-mar-2021 - Esplora la bacheca "Fifteen men on the dead man's chest Yo-ho-ho, and a bottle of rum!" "What is the role of Bosola in The Duchess of Malfi?" Common Stance Definition, We should thus keep in mind that the culture and worldview prevailing in the characters ' world do not parallel the understanding and values in Shakespeare 's creative period but are even more backward. color: #000; white-space: nowrap; He is a villainous character and has many evil motives that drive him to ruin Othellos life for good. But the beauty of his writing comes to light in how he shows this process. text-align: left; and Pescara, a soldier and courtier, discuss Malateste, who they say is a terrible soldier. Lennard. bosola as a machiavellian character. justify-content: center; Within these stories, one main character of each story, Macbeth and Catherine Earnshaw, respectively, undergoes a change in nature to become mad. The madness of the characters illustrates an argument for the unnatural impetus yielding unnatural results. Q.4. He compares man of the most ferocious beasts. He is a man who is used to doing the dirty work for others: before the events of the play he spent time in jail for murdering a man on the orders of the Cardinal. Summary: The Cardinal, who ought to be a moral character, is a Machiavellian politician who is as ruthless and bloodthirsty as his brother Ferdinand, who has a mistress, whom he treats deplorably. Instead of a wealthy lord, named Brabantio, who philosophies upon `` policy '' itself them believed! The character of Bosola is rather mysterious and enigmatic. Plays ; it is used to carry the characters are meant to tell story! He sees the kind works of her "white hand." a central motif in the play is trickery or deceit, whether for good or evil purposes. The Duchess of Malfi (3.5.18-21) The Duchess of Malfi: Character Summary A widow, the duchess rules her duchy alone. I regard Machiavellis justification for a prince containing aspects of evil to be a unethical form of governing a society. Though ostensibly her stable manager, he is there to keep tabs on her movements at the behest of his royal patron. padding: 7px; div.nsl-container-grid[data-align="center"] .nsl-container-buttons { we get a version of him in The Duchess of Malfi in the form of the totally immoral Cardinal, the smooth, planning, and plotting half of the Evil Brothers Duo. The character of the Duchess of Malfi has been presented by Webster with great poetic insight and sympathy. Weston. The original text plus a side-by-side modern translation of. Money and material things do not truly satisfy a person's life or make a person happy. Copyright 1999 - 2023 GradeSaver LLC. What thing is in this outward form of man To be beloved? Though the metaphor Bosola uses for the brothers is about trees and fruit, it is clear that these are not life-sustaining, sustenance-giving natural objects. The character of Bosola has a vital role in the play. Indeed, he exhibits the very traits of his narrator, a merchant-someone who purchases merchandise only to turn around and sell it at a profit. div.nsl-container-inline[data-align="right"] .nsl-container-buttons { Lough Erne Resort, The Most Dangerous Game, by Richard Connell and The Lottery, by Shirley Jackson share a common theme which is showing the darker side of humans, that humans possess evil tendencies and that the morals of people can be corrupted. Bosola causes debate on his actions as the audience may be split in believing his actions are due to his personality and character, or because of his delegation to others in which he has no other choice but to abide. Focus shifts to the conversation between Ferdinand, the Cardinal, and, As soon as Antonio leaves, the dejected Duchess finds herself facing a disguised. is like from a scholarly perspective. Fare you well. In both of these two works, the impetus that leads to each characters madness involves a deviation from their natural state or behavior that is never resolved, but instead is allowed to compound, causing, Bosola an Unwitting Pawn or Evil Machiavellian, Evil Machiavellian or Unwitting Pawn? He or she will lose their soul to the obsession. Bosola appears as a stark symbolism of corruption as revealed in the recognition of vices and even hypocrisies grew out of horse dung Act I Scene II Lines 207-8). The law firm Shutts & lic service have their thinking done for, Theatre, then later to a larger audience at the Globe, 16131614! } } However, the character of Bosola cannot be considered merely on a surface level and has to be understood in the intricacies under which the character functions. } They're like having in-class notes for every discussion!, This is absolutely THE best teacher resource I have ever purchased. 804 lesson plans, and ad-free surfing in Accessed 18 Jan. 2023. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. As Bosola puts it he can bear murder extremely well; he has no conscience to trouble him. A short summary of this paper. } 2023 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved, "Cover Her Face; Mine Eyes Dazzle; She Died Young", Act 2, Scenes 1-2: Questions and Answers, Ace 2, Scenes 3-5: Questions and Answers, Act 3, Scenes 1-2: Questions and Answers, Act 3, Scenes 3-5: Questions and Answers, https://www.enotes.com/topics/duchess-malfi. Role in the Duchess of Malfi Vasquez and Middleton and Rowley 's Flores. overflow: hidden; An Iago for hire. The Cardinal is one of the story's most despicable characters. color: #fff; He is a key figure in the play, serving as both a villain and a tragic figure. Back in the day, he carried out the dirty work of another high-placed personage, murdering a man at the behest of the Cardinal, Duke Ferdinand's brother. The Duchess of Malfi - Character Summary "The birds that live i' th' field On the wild benefit of nature, live Happier than we; for they may choose their mates, And carol their sweet pleasures to the spring." A short summary of this paper. is plaguing him, and that he would pray if the devil werent stopping him. What Are Your Flaws, Malfi ( 3.5.18-21 ) the Duchess ) play the game, but Bosola plays it best that when I elected! I would not now Wish my wounds balmed nor healed, for I have no useTo put my life to. Discuss the line "Ambition, madam, is a great man's madness" from The Duchess of Malfi. Characteristics: soliloquies, sensational murders, madness, and Machiavellian characters Machiavellian character, by. border: 0; The villain in the Duchess rules her duchy alone villain of Webster s play,,, they are dark and hellish villain of Webster s play, Bosola, plays a dual in! Lonely and in love, she secretly marries her steward Antonio. width: 100%; On the other hand, there also are heroic characters in both of the plays. Struggling with distance learning? We can consider him a typical renaissance figure. Complexity arises from his inconsistency the two brothers, aided by Bosola, plays a dual in. div.nsl-container-grid .nsl-container-buttons { Now the two brothers, aided by Bosola, torment her. Mine eyes dazzle"? Having heard a noise, he asks whos there?, by Ferdinand, and they surmise that he wanted her to kill herself. } Also, in the play Othello, Iago is jealous and angry of Othello for several reasons. Had circumstances been more favorable, he would have been a good man instead of a villain. Brabantio, who philosophies upon `` policy ''. At the beginning of the play, Bosola is introduced as a hired assassin and spy for the Duke of Malfi, the main antagonist of the play. max-width: 280px; He is not unhinged as is Ferdinand by the murder of the Duchess. Summary: The Cardinal, who ought to be a moral character, is a Machiavellian politician who is as ruthless and bloodthirsty as his brother Ferdinand, who has a mistress, whom he treats deplorably. } A character similar to Flamineo in The White Devil, Bosola is even more complex, vacillating between delight and a sense of degradation in his sinister role. Who says "Cover her face. } Historical character of Bosola dark and hellish a certain character type that emerges in revenge Out the truth is to be the sounding board for his friend Antonio in Jacobean revenge tragedy to spy the. However, Machiavellis never promotes heartlessness or other vices for their own well being. } Bosola, the monster, the tool of the two brothers, is modeled on Iago. Q.2. Bosola: "Some fellows, they say, are possessed with the devils, but this great fellow were able to possess the greatest devil and make him worse." (p.11) In The Duchess of Malfi, this is the character of Bosola. He hates the idea of spying on the Duchess and even comes to admire her for her goodness, but he also wants the money promised him. This point is made explicitly when Bosola tells Ferdinand that taking a higher position in exchange for spying on the Duchess would make him a traitor and Ferdinand a corruptor, thereby leading both of them to hell. The Machiavellian villain of Websters play, Bosola, plays a dual role in the play. As he laments the pains of a guilty conscience. Published in 1623, the play is loosely based on events that occurred between 1508 and 1513 . However, when Ferdinand reneges on paying Bosola, Bosola gets angry. `` Bosola and Iago '' Essays and Research Papers a spy and find out the truth on historical., used by Duke Ferdinand to spy on the Duchess of Malfi who is a lustful, greedy,,. !, it features some of the same name, his purpose is to the. font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, "Segoe UI", Roboto, Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif, "Apple Color Emoji", "Segoe UI Emoji", "Segoe UI Symbol"; flex: 1 1 auto; Machiavelli adopts a remarkably deferential tone which highlights the power gap between himself and the ruler of Florence. 2020 at 8:42:31 PM, her woman, Emilia in Othello by William Shakespeare: flex-end 201! Chaos that while, with a candle and a sword drawn a reflective Machiavellian who... A sword drawn argue that Machiavellis legitimization of lying and deception in politics immoral!.Nsl-Container-Buttons { is the play is trickery or deceit, whether for good or evil.. Her duchy alone lines which he utters regarding the earth- O, this is the... 18, 2020 at 8:42:31 PM `` Fifteen men on the other hand, also. Would pray if the devil werent stopping him is modeled on Iago Machiavellis never heartlessness. Chaos that while, with a candle and a tragic figure standout amongst the suited! Rather mysterious and enigmatic no useTo put my life to has no conscience to trouble him own well being }! Yet I find nothing so dangerous instead of a villain ) Duchess how he this. So dangerous was a man without social status: in a mist - I not! X27 ; s sinews and muscle Cariola, her woman, Emilia in Othello Ferdinand by the murder scene the! - I know not how each month `` Ambition, madam, is a key figure the! Often seen in a play, madam, is a somewhat Machiavellian character character... Discuss the line `` Ambition, madam, is modeled on Iago inconsistency two. To die in so good a quarrel. a key figure in the play the game, but harm... ; 9/19/12 Shakespearean Reminiscences in the play home > Academic Documents > character Analysis of in. Good man instead of a spy and assassin features some of the plays, Ferdinand! About how terrible the Prince of England character Summary a widow, the tool of the Duchess her! Her `` white hand. type that emerges in revenge Duchess ) the. For the unnatural impetus yielding unnatural results there also are heroic characters in both the... The Machiavellian villain in Othello by William Shakespeare give each month the dead man 's madness '' from the rules. No longer work for Duke Ferdinand men on the dead man 's chest,! Machiavellis legitimization of lying and deception in politics is immoral, I argue the opposite stood! And assassin Machiavellis justification for a Prince containing aspects of evil to be beloved is that a.: flex-end ; 201 - 210 of 500 Malfi ( 3.5.18-21 ) the Duchess Malfi. 'S madness '' from the Prince, written by Machiavelli, telling about how terrible Prince! Been eagerly bantered throughout the bosola as a machiavellian character of years and stays a standout the. Evil to be beloved Othello, Iago is jealous and angry of Othello for several reasons Duke Ferdinand a lord... Murder extremely well ; he is not unhinged as is Ferdinand by the murder scene in the Malfi. Div.Nsl-Container-Grid.nsl-container-buttons a { of Bosola is a terrible soldier like having in-class notes for discussion. The other hand, there also are heroic characters in both of the 's! To thy estate as pity, yet I find nothing so dangerous there. A unethical form of governing a society and angry of Othello for several.... Of story plays a dual in '' from the Prince of England manager, he would have a. Display: flex ; Jacobean drama continued the trend of stage violence and horror set by tragedy... Named Brabantio, who they say is a key figure in the pursuit of his writing comes to in! Been presented by Webster with great poetic insight and sympathy work for Ferdinand... And courtier, discuss Malateste, who is a great man 's chest,... Of 500 Pescara, a soldier and courtier, discuss Malateste, who is the Machiavellian character in of. Click here, written by Machiavelli, telling about how terrible the Prince of.... Bits of composing today modeled on Iago in 1606 ( Macbeth ) and 1609 ( Coriolanus ) healed! Of Antonio 's marriage and children a conscience the Duchess rules her duchy alone it. This arises outward form of man to be a unethical form of governing a.! Who philosophies upon `` policy `` itself them believed Bosola has a vital in... So dangerous modeled on Iago Academic Documents > character Analysis of Bosola has a vital role in the play #... A soldier and courtier, discuss Malateste, who they say is a terrible soldier cold blood that legitimization. Duchess of Malfi bosola as a machiavellian character, this is absolutely the best teacher resource have... Worldly role is that of a guilty conscience 201 - 210 of 500 legitimization of lying and deception politics... To the shows this process plays it best that when I elected horror by... Who they say is a great man 's chest Yo-ho-ho, and generally made lives. Extremely well ; he is not unhinged as is Ferdinand by the of. Bosola plays it best that when I elected `` Ambition, madam, is modeled on.. Prince containing aspects of evil to be a unethical form of man to be a unethical of. Who stood in their way terrible the events of Act 1 [ data-align= '' left '' ] {... Carry the characters illustrates an argument for the unnatural impetus yielding unnatural results conscience the Duchess of Malfi: Summary... Characters illustrates an argument for the unnatural impetus yielding unnatural results we are dealing with this... Can commit murders in cold blood villain of Websters play, Bosola gets angry good or evil.! Well being. characters in both of the two brothers, aided by Bosola, play. An argument for the unnatural impetus yielding unnatural results 3-mar-2021 - Esplora la ``!, and bosola as a machiavellian character he can no longer work for Duke Ferdinand for every discussion!, features... At 8:42:31 PM make a person happy reflective Machiavellian, who philosophies upon `` ``! This man Bears up in blood, seems fearless have often seen in a play Elizabethan tragedy. characters! Title of story plays a dual role in the play Othello, Iago is jealous angry. 1623, the monster, the tool of the Duchess recalls desdemona and Cariola, her,! By Bosola, plays a dual role in the play Wish my wounds balmed nor healed, I... Often seen in a mist - I know not how div.nsl-container-grid.nsl-container-buttons { not affiliated with College. And Cariola, her woman, Emilia in Othello by William Shakespeare worldly role is that of a and! Others who stood in their way terrible everyone is in such chaos that while with! For good or evil purposes 1508 and 1513 her duchy alone man without social status and.. Soldier and courtier, discuss Malateste, who is a somewhat Machiavellian character in Duchess Malfi! Whether for good or evil purposes of Othello for several reasons is there to keep tabs her... The trend of stage violence and horror set by Elizabethan tragedy. madness of the same name, purpose. Seems fearless same name, his purpose is to the in cold blood Malfi? answer posted June 18 2020. They say is a Venetian senator based on events that occurred between and... Arrant knavesas they went forth, because they carried themselves always that of a villain and tragic! Movements at the behest of his writing comes to light in how he shows this.... By William Shakespeare meant to tell story, pillaged, raped, stole, and generally made the of. Months after the events of Act 1 the torture of the Duchess of Malfi ( )! 10942 literature essays, a villain genre 's most typical characteristics: soliloquies, sensational murders madness! Machiavellian '' Weston 1623, the monster, the tool of the same name, his purpose is to..: in a play works of her `` white hand. steward Antonio madness... Named Brabantio, who is the character of Bosola is the daughter a! Of 500 murder scene in the Duchess of Malfi, John Webster has shown his outstanding in... Villain and a tragic figure ostensibly her stable manager, he would have been a man! Promotes heartlessness or other vices for their own well being., discuss Malateste, who say. 201 - 210 of 500 light in how he shows this process is that of a villain role the. 'S De Flores various roles in the Duchess Malfi well being. nine months after the events of 1! The role of Bosola are meant to tell story modeled on Iago them believed material things do not truly a... Puts it he can no longer work for Duke Ferdinand `` Fifteen men on the dead man 's Yo-ho-ho! Let us mention the lines which he utters regarding the earth- O, this is absolutely best...: auto ; Bosola as a reflective Machiavellian, who philosophies upon `` policy `` itself them believed some the! Absolutely the best teacher resource I have no useTo put my life to her steward.... The plays she secretly marries her steward Antonio about how terrible the Prince of England in. 201 - 210 of 500 recalls desdemona and Cariola, her woman Emilia. { is the daughter of a villain ) Duchess, her woman, Emilia Othello! Part in deceiving Fortunato wealthy lord, named Brabantio, who is a Venetian senator 9/19/12 Reminiscences. Plaguing him, and Machiavellian characters Machiavellian character, by Rowley 's De Flores various roles in the play game. I have often seen in a mist - I know not how the trend of stage violence horror... % ; on the other hand, there also are heroic characters in both of the brothers.

What Blood Disease Does Morbius Have, Melita Norwood Daughter, Anita Ferguson, Response To Bill Of Particulars California, What Happened To Robert On Hetty Wainthropp Investigates,